A couple of months ago I got a ride in that area from Fort Myers airport, so I decided to give the airport a try. They're only about six cars ahead of me so I figured this will be nice and quick. Nope, I sat there for almost an hour and only three cars moved ahead of me. What a waste of time that was
PGD works nice at night. It is a small airport, a few months ago there was no queue so you could get a trip from the airport getting the request in downtown Punta Gorda or in the vicinity. During the day local friends and family pick the people so even if it says 1-5 it may mean hours.